There are at least two sides to every story, and the unfortunate reality of “Stand Your Ground” cases is that the shooter, all too often, is never prosecuted as the other individual is deceased and stripped of his or her ability to tell their side of the story.
Such was the case of Joe Horn of Pasadena, Texas, who left the safety of his house, against the express instructions of a 9-11 dispatcher, and shot 2 unarmed men in the back and killed them as they were leaving a neighbor’s home after successfully robbing it on November 14, 2007. He was subsequently cleared of any wrongdoing by a Harris County grand jury on June 30th of 2008.
So, one might reasonably ask why this is news halfway through 2015. Two reasons immediately come to mind: firstly, over half of the states in America have some version of “Stand Your Ground” laws on the books, while several other states are considering such measures due in large part to the efforts of the NRA and national conservative groups such as ALEC.
Secondly, unlike with the Trayvon Martin case and other tragedies, there is a full audio tape of the entire incident, and there is a video recording of the initial police interview of Joe Horn as well – leaving no doubt as to where culpability lies. (Both are attached below).
The problem in the Joe Horn case is not the specific circumstances of the case, rather it is the nature and end result of the clearly deficient Castle Doctrine and the greater problems associated with the newer Stand Your Ground statutes.
The most damning portion of the audio recording is presented below:
[Mr. Horn then said he would get his shotgun.]
[The operator told him not to go out with a gun because officers would be arriving.]
There were two quick gunshots, then a third.
“I had no choice,” Mr. Horn said when he got back on the line with the dispatcher. “They came in the front yard with me, man.”
The 9-1-1 call ended about 80 seconds after the shots were fired, when officers arrived on the scene.
You can listen to the full 911 recording in the video below, followed by a video recording of the police walk through of the scene with Joe Horn shortly after the shooting (in 2 parts).
Joe Horn Police Investigation Footage 1
Joe Horn Police Investigation Footage 2